SlimFast Review | Diet Shakes That Work, But Are Not Great

In this Slimfast review, I shall have a look to one of the best known diet shake manufacturers.

As a matter of fact, Slim Fast has been around since 1977, and we could argue it is the original meal replacement. However, in the eyes of modern complete food consumer, it’s also the devil.

For those enjoying the Renaissance of meal replacements thanks to Soylent, Slimfast shakes represent all the bad: shakes marketed for weight loss, full of sugars, lack of nutrients or good quality ingredients, etc. Aka, in theory they are not for healthy or normal people; whereas modern complete foods are for anybody.

So today, I am here to review Slim Fast, to learn if they are truly as bad as people say, and if ultimately they should be consider a meal replacement.

Slim Fast products review

Slim Fast at a Glance


Opinion

In all honesty, I had very low hopes coming to this Slim Fast review.

While I had some positive surprises, like the variety Slim Fast offers to its customers, I was also reiterated on my believes.

In short, Slim Fast can be a good shake for those looking to start a weight loss journey the first time. They offer plenty of variety, a plan and a service (app) that can help you with that goal.

However, for anyone who’s looking to transition to a healthy lifestyle, Slim Fast shakes will fall short. Nutritionally they are average at best, taste is sickeningly sweet, and I didn’t feel full after consuming them.

What I like

1. Variety. Powder meal replacements, RTDs, bars and snacks. Slim Fast offers you plenty of nutritionally complete meals.

2. Good bundles for beginners. On top of that, they have multiple bundles that can be very helpful to plan out your weekly meals; in particular, if you are a beginner

3. Slim Fast Original is very affordable.

4. Can be used for weight loss.

5. Widely available, and also can be purchased in stores.

What I dislike

1. Nutritionally lacking. Firstly, not all products are nutritionally complete. Secondly, even the original shake might be lacking essential nutrients. Thirdly, ingredients are low quality

2. Not good for long term use. For long term healthy lifestyle, I would recommend you looking for other complete food brands that focus more in nutrition.

3. Everything was excessively sweet.

4. The Slim Fast ready-to-drink was quite watery.

5. There are much better alternatives out there. Both for weight loss purposes and regular use.

Nutritional Breakdown

Slim Fast has many products that feature different nutritional profiles, like their Keto shakes or their high protein ones. However, there are few common nutritional features: they tend to contain artificial sweeteners, no real food based ingredients, and generally low quality nutrient sources.

Slim Fast Original Nutrition Overview

Note: The Original shakes recommend adding skimmed milk for complete nutrition. Also, the US and UK Slim Fast shakes are different nutritionally.

Slim Fast
Kcal/meal227
Macros (C/P/F)45/36/19
VeganNo
KetoNo*
Features
Non-GMONo
OrganicNo
Includes ProbioticsNo
Artificial SweetenersYes
Synthetic AdditivesYes
Contains All MicronutrientsYes
Controversial IngredientsMaltodextrin, soy bean oil
*Slim Fast also sells a keto shake

Ingredients: skimmed milk powder, maltodextrin, inulin, soya bean oil powder (milk), natural flavouring, thickeners (xanthan gum, sodium carboxymethyl cellulose), vitamins & minerals1 (potassium phosphate, magnesium oxide, vitamin C, vitamin E, iron pyrophosphate, zinc sulphate, niacin, vitamin A, pantothenic acid, biotin, manganese sulphate, vitamin B12, potassium iodide, sodium selenite, folic acid, vitamin D, copper sulphate, vitamin B6, thiamin, riboflavin, vitamin K), milk protein, colour (curcumin), salt, sweetener (sucralose).

Ingredients: coconut oil powder (milk), calcium caseinate (milk), fat-reduced cocoa powder (19%), medium chain triglyceride powder (7%) (milk), avocado oil powder (3%), flavouring (milk), stabilisers (xanthan gum, sodium carboxy methyl cellulose), salt, sweeteners (sucralose, acesulfame K), vitamin B6, zinc oxide, vitamin B12.

Protein

Per 227kcal serving:

  • Total Protein: 15g, 30% of DV.
  • Source: Milk proteins.

There’s no denying that Slim fast shakes are high in protein. Most of them use a combination of added milk proteins and those who are naturally occurring in milk (when you add skimmed milk).

Both are complete protein sources that will provide you with easily absorbable amino acids.

Fats

Per 227kcal serving:

  • Total Fats: 2.9g, 3% of DV.
  • Saturated Fats: 0.6g, 1% of DV.
  • Omega-3s (ALA)?.

When it comes to fats, here’s were we see some of the first deficiencies.

Not only the original Slim Fast extremely low in fats, but it also lacks some essential fatty acids, like omega-3.

Furthermore, the fat source used is soy bean oil powder, which is not very common in the industry. Soy bean oil is rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids, and low in monounsaturated and saturated fatty acids. The main issue is that soy oil can often be hydrogenated or from GMO origin.

Carbs

Per 227kcal serving:

  • Total Carbs: 33g, 11% of DV.
  • Sugars: 21g.
  • Of which added: 10g, 18% of DV.*
  • Fibre: 4g, 8% of DV.

In the US version, the first ingredient of the Slim Fast shakes is sugar; whereas in the UK is skimmed milk. Thus, in the US you will have a lot of added sugars, whereas in the UK version you’ll have naturally occurring sugars in milk (lactose).

The second source of carbohydrate is maltodextrin, a complex carbohydrate with high glycemic index (85). This is, it will break down rapidly and raise your blood sugars.

All in all, Slim Fast’s carb sources are very refined and low in nutrients.

Micronutrients

On the positives, at least you will get a good dose of vitamins and minerals. Each shake contains at least 15% of 24 vitamin and minerals, including, 35% of vitamin A, D, 32% of vitamin C, 30% of DV of iron etc.

Allergens

The Original Slimfast shakes contain milk and soy.

Tasting Test

As part of my Slimfast review, I had a few different products tested, including: meal bars, powder based meal replacements, ready-to-drink meals and some snacks.

All of the above were part of the 7 day starter kit. The Keto shake was bought aside.

Slim Fast starter pack
Slim Fast Starter Pack
Slim Fast starter pack review
Meal bars, RTDs and snacks.
Best flavourKeto Chocolate
TasteSweet and artificial. Easy to like, but hard to enjoy in the long run
TexturePowder based shakes mixed really well, creating thinner and smooth shakes.
Easy to MixGreat mixability
SatietyOk. I have had diet shakes that have kept me full for longer. Good for about 1h30min
Easy to CleanYes, no issues
AfterthoughtsAll products felt too artificial and sweet. I got bored of them fast, and I could not have them in a daily basis

Holy Moly, This is Candy

I could describe most flavours with one word: sweet. In fact, all the shakes and bars were EXTREMELY sweet, with the exception of the snacks.

Therefore, you are warned. If you don’t like overly sweet, and noticeably artificially flavoured food, you won’t like Slim Fast.

And despite this harsh criticism, I can understand why people might wanna consume them. This sweetness makes them easier to like than the more natural, neutral meal replacement shakes.

Slimfast Original Shake Taste Review

Caffe Latte Powder Slim Fast

As a disclaimer, I must say that I only had 2 flavours. Even then, I’m pretty confident to say that all of them taste pretty similar: artificial and sweet.

For instance, Cafe Latte was similar to instant coffee with educolorants. The texture was fine, rather thin; so it’s not the worst shake ever.

The Keto Chocolate, on the other hand, was a little darker, but didn’t have the butteriness other keto shakes have. I would rather have something like Sated or HLTH, instead.

Slim Fast RTDs, Sweet Water

Slimfast RTD review

I’ve tried dozens of ready-to-drink meal replacements, but few have felt as watery as Slim Fast’s. There’s nothing wrong with all three flavours (Strawberry, Vanilla and Chocolate), but the consistency is just not there.

In fact, it almost feels like sugary water with some flavouring on top. Out of all three, Chocolate was the best in my opinion and I would stay away from Strawberry.

Slim Fast Bars

Slim Fast Choco Chip Bar
Choco Chip is much better than Very Berry.

As part of the Slim Fast weight loss bundle, I tried two different types of bars: the meal bars (Berry flavoured), and the snack bars (Caramel and Chocolate).

The latter were pretty nice, softer, more chocolaty and quite enjoyable.

As for the Berry meal bars, this were exceedingly sweet. My eyes twitched with the first bite. The rice pop like texture was fine, but the taste is just not there.

More about Slim Fast

Slim Fast logo

Slim Fast, One of the Original Meal Replacement Shakes

As mentioned in the introduction, SlimFast has been around since 1977. From its inception, Slim Fast has been focused on diet shakes to replace breakfast or lunch; and has a big market share in the US.

However, with the raise of “modern” meal replacements that aim to offer a healthy substitute to standard meals (not focused on weight loss); Slim Fast has been cornered to the diet spectrum even more.

That said, they have also expanded their range from powder to ready to drink, bars and snacks. All of them focused on providing you nutritious low calorie meals.

Slim Fast Products Reviewed

As part of 7 day weight loss bundle I was able to try out the various different options Slim Fast offers.

Slim Fast Original tub

Slim Fast Original

  • Powder Meal Replacement
  • 190kcal per serving
  • 10g of protein (from milk), 22g of sugar
  • 4 flavours to choose from
Slimfast keto tub review

Slim Fast Keto

  • Powder Meal Replacement
  • Ketogenic (low carb/high fats)
  • 190kcal, 8g of protein, 5g of carbs
  • 3 flavours
Slimfast original RTD

Slim Fast RTD

  • Ready to Drink Meal Replacement
  • 180kcal per serving
  • 10g of protein, 19g of sugar
  • 5 flavours
Slim fast Meal replacement bar

Slim Fast Bar

  • Meal Replacement bar
  • ~215kcal per serving
  • 15g of protein, 8g of sugar
  • 4 flavours

Beside these, I was also able to try some of the Slim Fast snacks which were around 100kcal per pack.

Slim fast 7 day starter bundle
The 7 day starter bundle includes 6 RTDs (2 of each flavour: strawberry, chocolate, cafe latte), various meal bars (very berry), some snack bars, and the flavour bites.

Is Slim Fast Good for Weight Loss?

So, obviously, the main aim of this starter bundle is to get you initiated and help you out with your weight loss journey. They offer some guidance, and include all sorts of meals so you don’t have any excuses.

However, Slim Fast (7 day bundle) is not worth the money if your aim is to lose weight or eat healthy.

Slimfast 7 day starter kit latestfuels review

Cons

Here are a few reasons why I think so:

  • Taste: As mentioned above, all Slim Fast products are obnoxiously sweet. The RTDs, the powders and even the meal bars. The Very Berry bar made my eyes twitch. That said, the Choco Chip one is ok and the other snacks are quite enjoyable, too.
  • Nutrition: none of them are intended to be extremely nutritious. They might cover some basics, but often lack key nutrients (omega-3, some vitamins) or are imbalanced. Sugars are often high, fibre is missing in many items, and generally they are quite carb heavy.
  • Not enough meals: lastly, it’s worth mentioning that there are too many snacks and not enough quality meals on the bundle. I would recommend getting some powder based meal replacements, too.
  • Not very filling: many of these items failed to make me feel full or satiated.

Pros

Nonetheless, there are some positives.

  • For instance, having so many options helps you not getting bored.
  • Besides, you can plan out quite easily your week and have a meal every time you need one.
  • Many of the meals are easy to carry with you, so that you can avoid any temptations.
  • All meals are relatively low-calorie, so that you can keep your calorie intake in check.

Alternatives

Therefore, here are some meal replacement shakes for weight loss that I can think they can help you out better:

Diet Extreme

  • 207kcal per serving, 1g of sugar, 4g of fibre, 24g of protein
  • Available in vegan and whey based versions
  • Up to 14 delicious flavours to choose from
  • Better tasting than Slimfast and more affordable
  • Unfortunately it doesn’t include any plans or bars or ready to go drinks

Exante Diet Bundle

  • ~110kcal per meal, 12g of protein, 3g of sugar
  • Includes bundles with bars and multiple meals for weight loss
  • Many flavours available, particularly in the UK
  • Better alternative to Slimfast in the UK, more affordable, more range and more bundles
  • Still a sweet shake that might fail to fill you up

Pricing and Shipping

Unfortunately, the pricing of Slim Fast shakes will depend on where you live.

In the US, you can buy directly from the manufacturer, as well as, Amazon and some other big retailers.

Price ($)$ per serving$ per 400kcal
Slim Fast Original (Powder)0.711.50
Slim Fast Keto (Powder)1.904.00
Slim Fast Original (RTD)2.255.00
Slim Fast Keto (RTD)3.006.67
Prices shown are for the smallest tub size in the Slimfast website.

In the UK and Europe, Slim Fast shakes are only available through 3rd party resellers and Amazon. Therefore, the price will depend on the 3rd party and can vary. Similarly, the products that you will be able to purchase might differ.

Slim Fast vs.

I’ve covered the best weight loss meal replacement shakes elsewhere, but in truth, this is the niche Slim Fast fits in the best. While they can be use for weight maintenance, too; Slim Fast markets the weight loss segment.

Previously, I’ve mentioned 2 of my favourite Slim Fast alternatives (Exante and Diet Extreme). You can see a small comparison table below:

Overview

Slim FastExanteDiet Extreme
serving price$0.71$2.86$3.30
kcal/serving227110207
Protein (g)151224
Sugar (g)2131
Fiber (g)454.2
Fats (g)333.4
Micronutrients232622
VeganNN*N*
OrganicNNN
Artificial SweetenersYYY
Synthetic AdditivesYYY
GMO?NN
Protein SourceMilkSoyWhey
Prices shown are most expensive option.

It’s worth noting that if you are looking for keto shakes to replace Slim Fast Keto, I would recommend HLTH Code or Sated.

The first, HLTH Complete Meal is nutritionally more well rounded with 50% of vitamins and minerals per serving. Furthermore, it has more nutrients, includes probiotics and digestive enzymes to help you with digestion. In fact, it’s one of the few keto shakes that doesn’t cause me stomach pain.

The latter is a complete keto shake that offers both powder and ready to drink meals that are more affordable than Slim Fast Keto shakes. They have a better texture and taste than Slim Fast Keto, and it’s much better for long term use.

Slimfast vs Shakeology

One of the most known diet shakes based in the US is Shakeology. Where Slim Fast offers affordable diet meals, Shakeology provides with premium nutrient rich shakes.

In fact, the two major differences in between both are price and the quality of ingredients. As mentioned, Shakeology goes for more natural ingredients, with tons of superfoods and vegetables added to the shake. On the contrary, Slim Fast opts for more processed and smaller ingredient list to provide you with just the essentials.

When it comes to taste, Shakeology is more complex, you can taste multiple flavours and the ingredients that comprise the shake. Slim Fast, on the other hand, is simpler, sweet and strongly flavoured.

In my opinion both are flawed, since Shakeology (while a good product) is grossly over priced, and Slim Fast (while cheap) is nutritionally lackluster.

Slimfast vs Atkins

Atkins offers meal replacement shakes that can easily be found in retail stores in the US. They are usually low carb, suitable for keto diets and focused on those who want to lose weight.

Again, both brands offer overly sweetened meal shakes with subpar ingredients. They can be quite tasty and easy to drink, but I think neither offers what a top meal replacement should have.

However, if you are trying to decide between Slim Fast Keto and Atkins, I would say try both and get the one you want. Neither will make a huge difference.

Slim Fast FAQ

Is Slim Fast good for weight loss?

Slim Fast shakes and bars can be an useful tool for losing weight. The variety and their diet plans can help easing beginners. However, for more advanced users, there are better weight loss meal replacement shakes in the market.

Is Slim Fast gluten-free?

Slim Fast shakes might contain traces of gluten, despite not having any gluten rich ingredients.

What’s the difference between Slim Fast Original and Keto shakes?

Slim Fast Original shakes contain more carbohydrates than the Keto drinks, and are the ones I would recommend for most people. Slim Fast Keto, on the other hand, is low in carbs and suitable for ketogenic diets.

Can I buy Slim Fast in Canada?

Yes, you can buy most Slim Fast products in Canada.

Slim fast keto shake review bars review

Verdict – Slim Fast Review

Coming to the end of this Slimfast review, I must admit that it’s exactly what I expected:

SlimFast shakes are weight loss oriented shakes that contain low quality ingredients, sickeningly sweet, and fail to satiate me when using them. As such, I believe that there are much better alternatives that will improve your diet further.

Nutritionally, Slim Fast just covers the basics and often fails to provide with all necessary nutrients. Plus, Slim Fast Original relies heavily on skimmed-milk to provide you with nutrients.

Nonetheless, it’s worth noting that the 7-day bundle can be helpful for those who are not sure where to start their weight loss journey. The variety of meals, together with some planning might be helpful for beginners to stick to their diets.

That said, I believe that there are better opportunities out there and I could not recommend Slim Fast meal replacement shakes for weight loss or daily usage.

Slim Fast

From $0.75/serving
3.8

Nutrition

3.3/5

Taste

3.8/5

Texture

4.0/5

Satiety

3.8/5

Price

4.3/5

Pros

  • Great variety of products: Bars, RTDs and powder
  • Superb bundles for beginners
  • Slim Fast Original is very affordable
  • Available in shops
  • Can help you with weight loss

Cons

  • Nutritionally lackluster
  • Wouldn't recommend for long term daily use
  • Most products are overwhelmingly sweet
  • There are better products out there
You might also like
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x